HP 910 Black, Cyan, Magenta, Black Ink Cartridge (Black XL + CMY)
Want the best price and purchase timing?
Our AI advisor analyzes real-time pricing across all channels to find you the best deal.
AI Verdict
This is a 5.6-ounce, high-yield ink cartridge set for specific HP OfficeJet 8010/8020 and OfficeJet Pro 8020/8030 series printers, delivering 825 black and 315 color pages.
This ink cartridge set is a situational fit because while it offers high yield for black ink (825 pages) and reliable print quality, it comes with significant user-reported issues like 'non-HP chip' errors and printer lockouts if color cartridges are empty or Instant Ink is canceled. Its compatibility is also limited to specific HP OfficeJet 8010/8020 and OfficeJet Pro 8020/8030 series printers.
If you need more consistent cartridge recognition and less restrictive printing, look for printers that do not enforce all-cartridge functionality for black-only printing.
Regret Score™
High RiskLower is better — measures purchase-regret risk from real buyer complaints, review credibility, and product maturity
Issues discovered after purchase
Critically weak dimension
Amazon rating vs actual quality
Chance this product isn't for you
Pros
- The black XL cartridge provides an approximate yield of 825 pages, reducing replacement frequency for high-volume black printing.
- Installation is straightforward, with printers recognizing cartridges immediately upon insertion.
- Print quality delivers sharp text and rich colors for both documents and photos.
- 82% of the ink cartridges are manufactured with recycled plastic, supporting environmental initiatives.
- Original HP Ink is designed to provide up to 2x more prints compared to non-Original HP Ink.
- The cartridges are compatible with a wide range of HP OfficeJet and OfficeJet Pro 8000 series printers, including 8010, 8015, 8022, 8025, 8028, and 8035 models.
Cons
- Users report that the ink can run out quickly, with some experiencing less than 10 pages from a cartridge.
- Some genuine HP cartridges are incorrectly detected as 'non-HP chip' by the printer, preventing use.
- The printer requires all color cartridges to be present and functional, even when only printing in black.
- Ink cartridges can dry out if the printer is not used frequently, leading to wasted ink.
- Canceling an HP Instant Ink subscription can render existing cartridges useless, forcing new purchases.
Dimension Scores
Installation is simple and the cartridges are recognized immediately by compatible printers.
Ink cartridges offer no user adjustability in their function or physical form.
While 82% of cartridges use recycled plastic, there are user reports of leaking cartridges and 'non-HP chip' errors even with genuine products.
The cartridges have a standard, functional design typical of printer consumables, with no particular aesthetic features.
Best For
- Users with HP OfficeJet 8010 or OfficeJet Pro 8020 series printers needing genuine HP ink for consistent performance.
- Home offices or small businesses that print frequently and benefit from the 825-page black XL yield.
- Individuals prioritizing print quality with sharp text and vibrant colors for documents and photos.
- Those who prefer the convenience of easy-to-install cartridges and seamless printer recognition.
Not Recommended For
- Budget-conscious users seeking lower-cost printing solutions, as original HP ink is priced higher than third-party alternatives.
- Infrequent printers, as cartridges may dry out before full usage, leading to wasted ink.
- Users who wish to print only in black when one or more color cartridges are empty or non-functional.
Watch Out For
- A new, genuine HP 910 color cartridge may be detected as a 'non-HP chip' by the printer, rendering it unusable.
- Some users report black ink cartridges not lasting long, with one user claiming less than 10 pages before running out.
- If you cancel an Instant Ink subscription, the printer may disable any existing Instant Ink cartridges, even if they contain ink.
- The printer will not allow printing, even in black, if any of the color cartridges are empty or not recognized.
- Cartridges can leak ink upon opening, making a mess and potentially damaging the printer.
Full Specifications
| ASIN | B07SZKCGFJ |
| Brand | HP |
| Color | Black |
| Ink Base | Water |
| Ink Color | Black |
| Page Yield | 825 |
| Item Weight | 5.6 ounces |
| Manufacturer | HP |
| Special Feature | High Yield |
| Item model number | 3JB41AN |
| Compatible Devices | Printer |
| Product Dimensions | 6 x 4.13 x 2.25 inches |
| Compatibility Options | Genuine |
What Buyers Say
The biggest headache with these HP 910 cartridges isn't just the cost; it's the frustrating 'non-HP chip' error that pops up even with brand-new, genuine HP ink, effectively bricking your printing until you troubleshoot or replace it. Many users also get caught by the fact that if any color cartridge runs out, you can't print anything, not even black and white. While the print quality is generally praised for sharp text and rich colors, the actual page yield often feels much lower than the advertised 825 black and 315 color pages, with some reporting cartridges running out after fewer than 10 prints.
“Seriously, I just want to print my kid's homework, but my printer keeps saying 'non-HP chip' on a cartridge I literally just bought from HP. This is ridiculous, I'm so over this ink drama!”
Common Praise
- The black XL cartridge lasts longer than standard cartridges for black-only documents.
- Print quality produces crisp, sharp text for documents.
- Colors are rich and vibrant for photo printing.
- Cartridges are easy to install and the printer recognizes them without issue most of the time.
- The packaging sometimes includes a disposal pouch for used cartridges.
- Original HP ink ensures consistent performance without smudging or fading.
Common Complaints
- Cartridges run out much faster than expected, sometimes after printing very few pages.
- Printers frequently display 'non-HP chip' errors for genuine HP cartridges, preventing printing.
- The printer stops working entirely if any single color cartridge is empty, even for black-only jobs.
- Ink dries out in the cartridge if the printer isn't used frequently, wasting the remaining ink.
- Canceling an Instant Ink subscription can lock out previously functional cartridges.
- Some cartridges arrive leaking ink, creating a mess and being unusable.
Ownership Tips
- Even if you only print black and white, you'll still need to replace all color cartridges when they run out.
- If you don't print for a few weeks, expect potential issues with dried-out ink or clogged nozzles when you try again.
- Be prepared for potential firmware updates from HP that might affect cartridge recognition or third-party ink use.
- The actual number of pages you get can be significantly less than the advertised yield, especially with mixed content.
- The cost of replacing all four cartridges can sometimes feel like buying a new printer.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are these cartridges compatible with my HP OfficeJet Pro 8025e?
Yes, these cartridges are compatible with the HP OfficeJet Pro 8025e, along with other models like the 8010, 8015, 8020, and 8035 series.
Can I print in black and white if my color cartridges are empty?
No, the printer requires all color cartridges to be installed and contain ink, even if you only intend to print in black.
What is the approximate page yield for these cartridges?
The black XL cartridge yields approximately 825 pages, and each color cartridge (cyan, magenta, yellow) yields about 315 pages.
Do these cartridges work with HP's Instant Ink program?
Yes, these cartridges are eligible for HP's Instant Ink program, which can automate ink deliveries.
I bought a genuine HP cartridge, but my printer says it's not genuine. What should I do?
Some users have reported genuine HP cartridges being incorrectly detected as 'non-HP chip' by the printer. This is a known issue with HP cartridges.
Will these cartridges dry out if I don't print often?
Yes, some users have noted that the ink can dry out over time if the printer is not used regularly, leading to wasted ink.
Buying Guide
When buying ink, you're not just getting colored liquid; you're buying into an ecosystem. You need to know your printer's exact model number because ink cartridges are highly specific. Also, understand that 'page yield' is an estimate based on 5% page coverage, so if you print photos or dense documents, you'll get fewer pages. Finally, be aware of any subscription services like Instant Ink, as they can change how your printer uses and recognizes cartridges.
Cartridge yield (approx.): 825 pages black, 315 pages per color
Compatibility: HP OfficeJet 8010, 8010e, 8012e, 8014e, 8015, 8015e, 8018, 8022, 8022e; HP OfficeJet Pro 8020, 8020e, 8024e, 8025, 8025e, 8028, 8028e, 8035, 8035e
Special feature: High Yield
Alternatives
If this ink doesn't fit your needs, look for printers that use ink tanks for much lower per-page costs, or models that allow black-only printing even with empty color cartridges.
You Might Also Like
LYMAX Computer Monitor Light Bar with Wireless Remote, Motion Sensor, Fit for Flat/Curved Monitor, Adjustable Color Temperature with Auto-Dimming, Eye-Care USB-C Monitor Lamp, No Glare Desk Lamp
$50-$99A 15.7-ounce aluminum monitor light bar with motion sensing, auto-dimming, and stepless 2700K-6500K color temperature adjustment for flat or curved screens.
Computer Monitor Lamp, Screen Monitor Light Bar for Eye Caring, Screen Monitor Light Bar with Backlight for Eye Caring, E-Reading LED Task Lamp with Dimming Adjustment, Perfect for Reading and Study
$0-$49This BLYGACN monitor lamp offers 3 color temperatures (3000K-6500K), dimming, and a 60-minute timer, powered by USB, for monitors 15-24 inches.
Monitor Light Bar with Touch Control, RGB Desk Lamp Full Spectrum Screen Lamp, Glare-Free Low Blue Light Monitor Lamp with Memory Mode, USB Powered for Gaming, Office & Work
$0-$49A USB-powered plastic monitor light bar with touch controls, RGB modes, and glare-free illumination for basic desk setups.
RGB Monitor Light Bar, Eye-Care Dual Light Reading Screen Lamp, 9 Modes Gaming Backlight LED Computer Lamp, 3 Colors Dimmable Frontlight, 15.75'' USB Desk Lights for Home, Office
$0-$49This is a budget-focused 6.4-ounce plastic monitor light bar with dual-mode lighting and 9 RGB backlight modes, designed for users needing basic task and ambient lighting without cluttering their desk