HP 58A (CF258A) Black Original Toner Cartridge
Want the best price and purchase timing?
Our AI advisor analyzes real-time pricing across all channels to find you the best deal.
AI Verdict
This 1-pound black toner cartridge delivers 3,000 pages for specific HP LaserJet Pro and Enterprise models, ideal for moderate office printing.
This HP 58A cartridge is a strong fit for its intended use with specific HP LaserJet printers, offering a 3,000-page yield and HP's anti-fraud technology. Its 88% recycled plastic content also aligns with sustainability goals. It's designed for consistent performance in moderate office environments.
If 3,000 pages isn't enough, look for high-yield versions like the HP 58X, which offers up to 10,000 pages, to reduce cost per page for heavier printing.
Regret Score™
High RiskLower is better — measures purchase-regret risk from real buyer complaints, review credibility, and product maturity
Issues discovered after purchase
Critically weak dimension
Amazon rating vs actual quality
Chance this product isn't for you
Pros
- Delivers approximately 3,000 pages, suitable for moderate printing volumes.
- Manufactured with 88% recycled plastic content, supporting sustainability.
- Engineered with HP anti-fraud technology to ensure authentic HP quality.
- Designed to prevent toner leaks and premature failures, ensuring consistent performance.
- Compatible with HP LaserJet Enterprise M430f, M406dn, LaserJet Pro M404dn, M404n, M428fdw, M428fdn, M404dw, M428dw printers.
Cons
- Initial cost is higher compared to some third-party alternatives.
- Limited compatibility, only working with specific HP LaserJet Enterprise and Pro models.
- Not designed for extremely high-volume printing needs, requiring more frequent replacements than high-yield options.
Dimension Scores
The cartridge is designed for seamless installation and quick replacement with auto seal removal and easy-open packaging.
As a toner cartridge, there are no adjustable features.
Engineered to prevent toner leaks and premature failures, with 88% recycled plastic content, ensuring durable and reliable performance.
The cartridge has a functional design typical of office consumables, with no specific aesthetic features highlighted.
Best For
- Offices with moderate black and white printing needs (around 3,000 pages per cartridge).
- Users of HP LaserJet Pro M404 and M428 series printers, or LaserJet Enterprise M406 and M430 series.
- Businesses prioritizing original HP quality, reliability, and anti-fraud technology.
Not Recommended For
- High-volume printing environments that require cartridges yielding 10,000+ pages.
- Users seeking the lowest possible cost per page, often found with compatible or remanufactured cartridges.
- Printers not listed in the compatible HP LaserJet Pro and Enterprise series.
Watch Out For
- Some users reported receiving defective cartridges that produced blank pages or heavy black lines on prints.
- The cartridge may have issues printing on specific paper types, such as letterhead, for some users.
- Non-original HP cartridges, even those advertised with a 'chip,' may not function correctly due to HP's network locking.
- The initial purchase price is often cited as expensive by users, despite perceived value.
Full Specifications
| UPC | 192018046757 |
| ASIN | B07QZ4ZKYG |
| Brand | HP |
| Color | Black |
| Page Yield | 3000 |
| Item Weight | 1 pounds |
| Manufacturer | HP |
| Special Feature | High yield (3,000 pages) and recycled content |
| Item model number | 58A |
| Product Dimensions | 4.02 x 14.25 x 7.8 inches |
| Included Components | Toner Cartridge |
| Compatibility Options | Works with these HP Printers: LaserJet Enterprise M430f,M406dn; LaserJet Pro M404dn,M404n,M428fdw,M428fdn,M404dw,M428dw |
| Printer Model Compatibility | HP LaserJet Enterprise M406dn, HP LaserJet Enterprise MFP M430F, HP LaserJet Pro M404DW, HP LaserJet Pro M404N, HP LaserJet Pro M404dn, HP LaserJet Pro MFP M428DW, HP LaserJet Pro MFP M428FDW, HP LaserJet Pro MFP M428Fdn |
| Is Discontinued By Manufacturer | No |
| Global Trade Identification Number | 00192018046757 |
What Buyers Say
Many users report consistent, professional-quality prints, but the recurring theme is the high cost of original HP toner. Some customers have experienced issues with defective cartridges right out of the box, leading to blank pages or print defects. There's also a strong sentiment against HP's system that often prevents non-original cartridges from working, forcing users to buy the more expensive HP brand.
“Ugh, another toner cartridge, feels like I just bought one. It prints fine, like it should, but man, the price always stings. And don't even think about trying a cheap knock-off, HP just blocks 'em.”
Common Praise
- Produces crisp, black text and graphics.
- Provides consistent print quality from page to page.
- Easy and seamless installation process.
- Reliable performance without premature failures.
- Long-lasting toner resistant to fading for document archiving.
Common Complaints
- High initial cost compared to compatible alternatives.
- Defective cartridges occasionally received, resulting in blank prints or lines.
- Problems with the printer recognizing non-HP cartridges, even with chips.
- Some users experienced issues printing on specific materials like letterhead.
Ownership Tips
- The printer's firmware updates can sometimes block previously working third-party cartridges.
- Keeping a spare on hand is a common practice, but some users found their spare was a dud when finally installed.
- The page yield of 3,000 pages is generally accurate for typical text documents.
- Recycling through HP Planet Partners is convenient and the cartridges are never sent to a landfill.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can this toner be used for archival purposes?
Yes, HP designs this toner to be long-lasting and resistant to fading, making it suitable for most standard document archiving needs.
Is this cartridge suitable for very high-volume printing?
While it has a 3,000-page yield, it's not ideal for extremely high-volume demands. For those needs, consider a high-yield toner cartridge like the HP 58X (10,000 pages).
Does this toner cartridge come in color?
No, the HP 58A (CF258A) is a black toner cartridge designed specifically for monochrome (black and white) printing.
What printers are compatible with this cartridge?
It works with HP LaserJet Enterprise M430f, M406dn, and LaserJet Pro M404dn, M404n, M428fdw, M428fdn, M404dw, M428dw series printers.
Are there issues with using non-HP cartridges with these printers?
Users report that non-original HP cartridges, even those claiming to have a 'chip,' may not work due to HP's security features, leading to wasted supplies.
Buying Guide
When buying toner, you're mostly paying for consistency and compatibility. You need to match the cartridge model exactly to your printer, or you'll just waste money. Page yield tells you how many prints you'll get, but your actual mileage might vary based on what you print. Original cartridges usually cost more but tend to avoid compatibility headaches.
Page Yield (3,000 pages)
This number tells you roughly how many standard pages (5% coverage) you can expect to print before needing a replacement. Think of it like the 'miles per gallon' for your printer – higher numbers mean fewer refills.
Compatibility (HP LaserJet Pro/Enterprise series)
This is crucial; a toner cartridge is like a specific key for a specific lock. If your printer model isn't listed, it simply won't work, no matter how similar it looks.
Original vs. Compatible
'Original' means it's made by HP, designed to work perfectly with their printers and often includes anti-fraud tech. 'Compatible' are third-party versions, usually cheaper, but can sometimes trigger printer warnings or fail to work due to HP's security.
Alternatives
If this cartridge is too expensive or doesn't last long enough, look for high-yield versions of the same model number for a lower cost per page, or explore compatible cartridges if you're willing to risk potential compatibility issues.
You Might Also Like
LYMAX Computer Monitor Light Bar with Wireless Remote, Motion Sensor, Fit for Flat/Curved Monitor, Adjustable Color Temperature with Auto-Dimming, Eye-Care USB-C Monitor Lamp, No Glare Desk Lamp
$50-$99A 15.7-ounce aluminum monitor light bar with motion sensing, auto-dimming, and stepless 2700K-6500K color temperature adjustment for flat or curved screens.
Computer Monitor Lamp, Screen Monitor Light Bar for Eye Caring, Screen Monitor Light Bar with Backlight for Eye Caring, E-Reading LED Task Lamp with Dimming Adjustment, Perfect for Reading and Study
$0-$49This BLYGACN monitor lamp offers 3 color temperatures (3000K-6500K), dimming, and a 60-minute timer, powered by USB, for monitors 15-24 inches.
Monitor Light Bar with Touch Control, RGB Desk Lamp Full Spectrum Screen Lamp, Glare-Free Low Blue Light Monitor Lamp with Memory Mode, USB Powered for Gaming, Office & Work
$0-$49A USB-powered plastic monitor light bar with touch controls, RGB modes, and glare-free illumination for basic desk setups.
RGB Monitor Light Bar, Eye-Care Dual Light Reading Screen Lamp, 9 Modes Gaming Backlight LED Computer Lamp, 3 Colors Dimmable Frontlight, 15.75'' USB Desk Lights for Home, Office
$0-$49This is a budget-focused 6.4-ounce plastic monitor light bar with dual-mode lighting and 9 RGB backlight modes, designed for users needing basic task and ambient lighting without cluttering their desk