HP 58X Black Toner Cartridge Printers | Works with LaserJet Enterprise M406dn, MFP M430f; LaserJet Pro M404 Series, MFP M428 Series | CF258X
Want the best price and purchase timing?
Our AI advisor analyzes real-time pricing across all channels to find you the best deal.
AI Verdict
A 10,000-page high-yield black toner cartridge for specific HP LaserJet Enterprise and Pro printers, designed for consistent office printing.
This 10,000-page high-yield toner cartridge is a strong fit for high-volume office environments using compatible HP LaserJet Enterprise M406dn, M430f, or LaserJet Pro M404/M428 series printers. Its integrated chip and HP engineering aim for consistent print quality and reliability, minimizing interruptions.
If your print volume is lower or you prioritize budget over OEM guarantees, consider a standard yield (58A) cartridge or a reputable third-party alternative with a proven track record for your specific printer model.
Regret Score™
Low RiskLower is better — measures purchase-regret risk from real buyer complaints, review credibility, and product maturity
Issues discovered after purchase
Critically weak dimension
Amazon rating vs actual quality
Chance this product isn't for you
Pros
- Delivers approximately 10,000 pages at 5% coverage, reducing replacement frequency.
- Engineered for specific HP LaserJet Enterprise M406dn, M430f and LaserJet Pro M404/M428 series printers.
- Produces consistently sharp prints with deep, clean blacks.
- Includes a built-in chip for seamless printer communication and accurate toner level monitoring.
- Designed to prevent toner leaks and premature failures, maintaining print quality.
- Manufactured with 88% recycled plastic, aligning with environmental considerations.
Cons
- Higher upfront cost compared to many third-party alternatives.
- Strictly compatible with a limited range of HP LaserJet printers, restricting broader use.
- Some users report receiving fewer pages than the advertised 10,000, with one instance of a cartridge lasting only 6 months.
- The cartridge has a noticeable weight, which could be a factor for bulk handling.
Dimension Scores
Engineered to prevent leaks and premature failures, with users reporting consistent, professional-grade print quality over thousands of pages.
Offers a high yield of approximately 10,000 pages, significantly more than standard cartridges, reducing replacement frequency.
Designed for seamless integration with a specific, though limited, range of HP LaserJet Enterprise and Pro printers.
HP reports that 88% of its ink cartridges are manufactured with recycled plastic.
Best For
- Offices with high-volume printing needs on compatible HP LaserJet printers.
- Businesses prioritizing original HP cartridge reliability and consistent print quality.
- Workflows where avoiding reprints and printer downtime is critical.
Not Recommended For
- Users seeking the lowest upfront cost per page from non-OEM cartridges.
- Printers outside the specified HP LaserJet Enterprise and Pro series.
- Casual home users with low print volumes.
Watch Out For
- Some users experienced cartridges lasting only 6 months, despite the 10,000-page yield, instead of the expected 12 months.
- Using non-genuine cartridges can lead to issues like printers not recognizing the cartridge or incorrect toner level reporting due to missing or incompatible chips.
- The cartridge is expensive, with some users noting the cost approaches that of a new printer.
- One user reported receiving the wrong cartridge from HP despite providing specific printer details.
Full Specifications
| UPC | 192018046764 |
| ASIN | B07QZ4Z3X9 |
| Brand | HP |
| Color | Black |
| Page Yield | 10000 |
| Item Weight | 1 pounds |
| Manufacturer | HP |
| Cartridge Type | Genuine |
| Special Feature | High Yield |
| Item model number | CF258X |
| Product Dimensions | 1 x 1 x 1 inches |
| Included Components | Toner Cartridge |
| Compatibility Options | Genuine |
| Printer Model Compatibility | HP LaserJet Enterprise M406dn, HP LaserJet Enterprise MFP M430F, HP LaserJet Pro M404DW, HP LaserJet Pro M404N, HP LaserJet Pro M404dn, HP LaserJet Pro MFP M428DW, HP LaserJet Pro MFP M428FDW, HP LaserJet Pro MFP M428Fdn |
| Global Trade Identification Number | 00192018046764 |
What Buyers Say
Many users highlight the consistent, sharp print quality and the extended life of the 10,000-page high-yield cartridge, which reduces the hassle of frequent replacements. However, the primary complaint revolves around its high price, with some feeling it's disproportionate to the cost of a new printer. While generally reliable, a few users have experienced cartridges not lasting as long as expected. The integrated chip is appreciated for seamless printer communication, but it also means compatible cartridges without proper chips can cause issues.
“Seriously, this 58X toner just works, prints look crisp every time, but man, my wallet feels lighter than the cartridge after buying it.”
Common Praise
- Prints consistently sharp text with deep, clean blacks.
- Lasts noticeably longer than standard yield cartridges, reducing interruptions.
- Easy to install and operates without problems.
- Produces professional-grade print quality even after thousands of pages.
- No toner dust, smudges, or print quality degradation.
- Includes smart security features within the chip.
Common Complaints
- The cartridge is expensive, sometimes nearing the cost of a new printer.
- Some users reported receiving significantly fewer pages than the advertised 10,000.
- Non-genuine cartridges often cause printer errors or inaccurate toner level readings due to chip incompatibility.
- One user specifically mentioned a cartridge lasting only 6 months instead of the previous 12.
Ownership Tips
- The printer's toner level indicator seems accurate with this genuine HP cartridge.
- Even after heavy use, print quality remains consistent without fading or streaking.
- The cartridge feels substantial and well-built, not flimsy.
- You really do get a lot of prints out of it, making fewer trips to reorder.
- The initial cost stings, but the lack of print issues makes it less frustrating than dealing with cheap compatibles.
Frequently Asked Questions
What printers is this HP 58X toner cartridge compatible with?
It works with HP LaserJet Enterprise M406dn, M430f, and LaserJet Pro M404 Series (M404dn, M404dw, M404n) and MFP M428 Series (M428fdw, M428fdn, M428dw) printers.
What is the approximate page yield of the HP 58X cartridge?
This high-yield cartridge is designed to produce approximately 10,000 pages at 5% page coverage.
Does this cartridge include a chip for printer communication?
Yes, the HP 58X toner cartridge has a built-in chip that communicates with your printer for functions like toner level monitoring.
Is the HP 58X cartridge made with recycled materials?
HP states that 88% of its ink cartridges are manufactured with recycled plastic, contributing to environmental efforts.
What is the difference between HP 58A and 58X toner cartridges?
The main difference is page yield; the 58X is a high-yield version designed for 10,000 pages, while the 58A is a standard yield cartridge, typically around 3,000 pages.
Buying Guide
When you're buying toner, you're essentially investing in your printer's performance and your document quality. For high-volume printing, a high-yield cartridge like this one means fewer interruptions and less time spent swapping out supplies. The trade-off is usually a higher upfront cost, but it can be more cost-effective per page in the long run if you print a lot.
Cartridge yield (approx.): 10,000 pages
This number tells you how many pages you can expect to print before needing a replacement, based on 5% page coverage. For busy offices, a higher yield means less frequent cartridge changes and more continuous printing.
Works with specific HP Printers (e.g., LaserJet Pro M404 Series)
Toner cartridges are highly printer-specific. Using the wrong one won't work and can even damage your machine, so always double-check your printer model against the compatibility list.
High Yield
"High Yield" indicates the cartridge contains more toner than a standard version, offering a lower cost per page and extended use, which is crucial for environments with heavy printing demands.
Alternatives
If this cartridge doesn't fit your budget, look for third-party compatible cartridges with verified chip functionality and strong user reviews for your specific printer model, or consider a standard yield cartridge if your print volume is lower.
You Might Also Like
LYMAX Computer Monitor Light Bar with Wireless Remote, Motion Sensor, Fit for Flat/Curved Monitor, Adjustable Color Temperature with Auto-Dimming, Eye-Care USB-C Monitor Lamp, No Glare Desk Lamp
$50-$99A 15.7-ounce aluminum monitor light bar with motion sensing, auto-dimming, and stepless 2700K-6500K color temperature adjustment for flat or curved screens.
Computer Monitor Lamp, Screen Monitor Light Bar for Eye Caring, Screen Monitor Light Bar with Backlight for Eye Caring, E-Reading LED Task Lamp with Dimming Adjustment, Perfect for Reading and Study
$0-$49This BLYGACN monitor lamp offers 3 color temperatures (3000K-6500K), dimming, and a 60-minute timer, powered by USB, for monitors 15-24 inches.
Monitor Light Bar with Touch Control, RGB Desk Lamp Full Spectrum Screen Lamp, Glare-Free Low Blue Light Monitor Lamp with Memory Mode, USB Powered for Gaming, Office & Work
$0-$49A USB-powered plastic monitor light bar with touch controls, RGB modes, and glare-free illumination for basic desk setups.
RGB Monitor Light Bar, Eye-Care Dual Light Reading Screen Lamp, 9 Modes Gaming Backlight LED Computer Lamp, 3 Colors Dimmable Frontlight, 15.75'' USB Desk Lights for Home, Office
$0-$49This is a budget-focused 6.4-ounce plastic monitor light bar with dual-mode lighting and 9 RGB backlight modes, designed for users needing basic task and ambient lighting without cluttering their desk